- Previously, you saw me out in the cold battling the elements, try... yeah, okay, it wasn't that bad. Anyway, I was out shootin' star trail pictures. I was trying to get one of those images where, or a couple of those images where I've got streaks of stars in the sky, and I was doing it using a method whereby I was taking lots of images at shorter shutter speeds, still very long, but shorter, so that I could stack them together. So, rather than shooting a single, 4-hour shot, I was shooting a series of 30-second shots, with the idea that they could be combined later.
Now, I'm gonna show you how to combine them. And I'm actually gonna show you how to combine a couple of images because it turns out the first one I shot didn't really work, but I wanna show you that one because there's something important that we can learn from it. So, I've copied the images over from my camera. I've got a whole bunch of JPEGs. Now, I actually shot in RAW, and to speed things up, I have converted those to JPEG. I did that in Photoshop using the Image Processor, which I can get to from Bridge. Select a bunch of images, choose Tools, Photoshop, Image Processor, and then I can have it run through and batch-process all of these from RAW into JPEG.
You may say, "Well, why not just shoot JPEG "in the first place?" and that's not a bad question. I would argue that it's best to shoot RAW because in that RAW conversion process, Photoshop is going to apply some noise reduction that might turn out to be really useful given that your're shooting a high ISO in the dark. So, I still like shooting in RAW. I also have white balance control that way. I could go through and do a batch white balance change on my images before I convert them to JPEG. But ultimately, I'm working with JPEGs, and I've got them all open in Bridge here. There are two ways that I can do this operation of stacking 'em.
I can select all my images in Bridge, and go to Tools, Photoshop, Load Files into Photoshop Layers. If I'm working in Lightroom, I can do the same thing. I can select all these images, right-click, and go to Edit In, and choose Load Files into Photoshop Layers. When I do that, it launches Photoshop if it's not open already, and loads all of these images into a single document with a separate JPEG file in each layer. So, what I've got is a bunch of images that are overlapping each other. I'm going to use the Blending Mode controls so that the images get blended together in a way where I see the streaks of stars all composited together.
Blending modes are found in this pop-up menu over here in the Layers palette, and what they do is control how pixels in one layer combine with pixels in the underlying layers. When Blending Mode is set to Normal, pixels in an upper layer completely overwrite pixels in a lower layer. This menu is full of all sorts of different options, and basically, they're just different mathematic or logical operators that can be performed between pixels. So, if I select all of these layers, which I can do by clicking on the topmost one, and going all the way down here to the bottom, I have 57 of them, holding down the shift key, and clicking on the bottom, that selects all the layers, I can then go here and switch to Lighten, and when I do that, poof, I have star trails.
Now, what Lighten is doing is it's saying to keep the pixel on top if it is lighter than the pixel below. So, I'm just going through and gathering up all the brightest pixels, and making them visible in this one single image. So, this is pretty cool, I've got star trails, you can even see that I've got some airplanes flying through, which I may want to do something about, we'll get to that later. The problem is I've got stuttery star trails. I've got Morse code star trails. It's a bunch of little dots. I wasn't expecting that. And fortunately, I reviewed this in the field.
I actually did this merge in the field to find out if my star trails were working, and the conclusion I came to was this is peculiarity of the way that the intervalometer that's built into my camera works. So, in my camera, I had long-exposure noise reduction turned on. That's a process called dark frame subtraction, so, after I shoot an image, the camera then sits there and shoots another image without opening the shutter, of the exact same duration, so basically, it's taking a picture of black so that it can get a record of what the noise is in the image.
And, noise varies depending on camera temperature and things like that, so it's gonna be a map specific to the time that I'm shooting. And then internally, it does some math to scrub that noise out of my RAW file before it saves it. So, if I'm doing a 30-second exposure after each shot, there's a 30-second delay while it does that dark-frame subtraction. It turns out that my intervalometer doesn't start its count until after that long-exposure noise reduction is done. The practical upshot is that it was a minute and a half between opening the shutter, and that was enough time that the stars were moving, and so my trails are overlapping.
So, I turned off the dark-frame subtraction, the long-exposure noise reduction and did it again so that I was truly getting an exposure every 30 seconds, and I ended up with another batch of images. I'm not gonna save this one 'cause my second one is better. And instead of doing this one in Photoshop, I'm going to do this one with a piece of freeware called StarStaX. This is available for the Mac and for Windows and for Linux, and it really streamlines this process. So, I'm gonna go over here to StarStaX.
It says, "Drop Images Here." On the Mac in the current version, you can't do that, it'll crash and there's a very big warning and a Readme file about that. This is apparently something that Apple needs to fix before it's gonna work, so I'm gonna use this open dialogue box instead, and just go here and select all of my images. And when I do that, they'll appear over here. Here's a Blending Mode menu. All I have to do is choose the mode I want. I'm gonna start by doing Lighten. I have a number of options here, and it's cool, 'cause if I mouse over it, it gives me a little Tool Tip that shows me what each different mode does, and this button is the Process button, Start Processing.
I click that, and I actually see the images start to blur together. The first thing you saw there was a tree pop into view, and that's because for one single frame, I painted the tree with a flashlight to illuminate it, 'cause I decided I wanted that in the foreground. What's cool about this technique is if I was just shooting a single long-exposure image, I would be stuck with that tree there. With this stacking procedure, if I decide that I don't like the tree lit up, I can just take that image out of the stack, and then I'm back to just a silhouette of a tree.
I could do the same thing with these pictures of planes. I could just take those out of the stack, just remove those images, and they won't go into my composite, and I will end up not having those streaks there. Or, I can go into those individual frames and clone the planes out in Photoshop, which is much easier to do on an individual image that doesn't have trails. So, this is the Lighten mode, and it's working pretty well. It may look like there's a lot of aliasing and stuff in here, but there's really not. That's just a function of my zoom level. If I zoom all the way in, you can see that I've got nice, clear star trails here that are nicely joined together.
I was right to change my interval. These gaps here are actually tree branches that I didn't get lit up with my flashlight, so they're occluding that part of that star trail. I do have another option that I may wanna play with. Sometimes these trails can have strange gaps kind of in the middle of them, so, I'm going to switch from Lighten mode to Gap Filling, and you can see in the Tool Tip here: Create star trail images with minimal gaps. Sounds great, I'm gonna actually just hit the processing button again, it throws out my old conversion, and starts a new one.
This one takes longer to process, so before you do this, you might just do a quick Lighten to see how it looks to see if you like your composition and everything and see if you think it's worthwhile. For all of these reasons, lower noise when shooting, a little more control when shooting because you're not going to be stuck with this very, very long exposure, and for the control that you get in post-production, the ability to take out frames with airplanes in them, or to experiment with painting different things. For all of those reasons, I'm just really sold on stacking as opposed to really long exposures as a way to do this.
And, the main thing, of course, is I'm minimizing noise. So, this is motoring along here, and here's my Gap Filled result. I don't see a huge difference between it and Lighten, but I like them both. I think I will go in and play with the planes. I'm gonna leave the tree lit up; I like it, but it's too cold, I think, in color temperature. So, I'm gonna warm that frame up a little bit. I don't think it'll warm the stars. If it does, I'll just mask those out. So, I've really got a fine level of control. Another cool thing I get out of this, for free, as a bonus, is a time-lapse.
It's not a really long time-lapse, but here you can see, I got a nice shot of the sky animating itself. Because I've got all these frames, I just throw those into another piece of freeware that I use on the Mac is Time Lapse Assembler. Really nice way of building time lapses. So, I get that for free. So, I really like this. I'm curious to see how it's gonna compare to the long-exposure star trails pictures that I did, and we're gonna take a look at that in a future Practicing Photographer.
Author
Updated
12/23/2020Released
5/19/2013Skill Level Beginner
Duration
Views
Q: Why can't I earn a Certificate of Completion for this course?
A: We publish a new tutorial or tutorials for this course on a regular basis. We are unable to offer a Certificate of Completion because it is an ever-evolving course that is not designed to be completed. Check back often for new movies.
Related Courses
-
Photography Foundations: Composition
with Ben Long5h 29m Intermediate -
The DIY Photographer
with Joseph "PhotoJoseph" Linaschke2h 39m Intermediate -
Photo Tools Weekly
with Chris Orwig26h 18m Intermediate
-
The Practicing Photographer - New This Week
-
16-bit in Photoshop6m 23s
-
-
Introduction
-
Previous Episodes
-
Choosing a camera5m 27s
-
Let your lens reshape you7m 26s
-
Working with reflections1m 26s
-
Exploring mirrorless cameras7m 25s
-
Using a tripod3m 33s
-
Wildlife and staying present5m 58s
-
Why Shoot Polaroid11m 12s
-
Seizing an opportunity4m 4s
-
Shooting wildlife7m 24s
-
Using a lens hood4m 48s
-
Working with themes2m 48s
-
Setting up an HDR time lapse7m 55s
-
Processing an HDR time lapse7m 55s
-
Scanning Photos5m 37s
-
Jpeg iPad import process3m 17s
-
Warming up3m 26s
-
Taking a panning action shot10m 17s
-
Shooting a silhouette3m 9s
-
Using Lightroom on the road6m 28s
-
Shooting level2m 42s
-
Photoshop and Automator8m 54s
-
Softboxes vs. umbrellas2m 55s
-
Working with hair in post3m 28s
-
Exploring how to use Bokeh5m 38s
-
Shooting stills from a drone6m 57s
-
Working with models2m 40s
-
Tips for shooting panoramas7m 16s
-
Dry sensor cleaning6m 23s
-
Composing in the center2m 48s
-
Vignetting9m 56s
-
Inspire3m 29s
-
Minimizing camera baggage4m 24s
-
Working without a tripod4m 11s
-
Printer options6m 51s
-
Exploring lo-fi printing options11m 58s
-
IOS macro photography gear12m 25s
-
IR Conversion Part 27m 27s
-
Raw editing in Lightroom mobile10m 35s
-
Shooting a macro insect shot13m 5s
-
A brief history of photography12m 19s
-
Shooting with a Petzval lens9m 49s
-
What is a low-pass filter?4m 35s
-
Teleconverters and lenses5m 12s
-
Media card care7m 19s
-
Dual slot4m 2s
-
Exploring smart previews9m 12s
-
Flying and photo batteries5m 41s
-
Partial vignettes on photos8m 38s
-
360 image editing plugins6m 59s
-
Using a gimbal with an SLR8m 13s
-
Choosing a lens6m 27s
-
Switching camera systems7m 42s
-
Using 360 drones5m 41s
-
VR gimbals4m 16s
-
Working with a photo subject14m 26s
-
Posing a photo subject12m 53s
-
Framing and safety7m 7s
-
RAW converter options3m 59s
-
Drone flight7m 19s
-
Basic abstract photography8m 51s
-
Aspect ratio3m 40s
-
Focus lock on your camera2m 11s
-
Using the Astropad app6m 33s
-
Working with dim sunlight6m 33s
-
Configuring dual cards2m 52s
-
Long lens options4m 45s
-
Moving images from catalogs7m 47s
-
Photography education11m 7s
-
In-camera focus stacking9m 52s
-
Exposure isn't everything4m 17s
-
Why shoot film?8m 55s
-
Culling4m
-
Choosing a film camera8m 38s
-
Analog workflow9m 9s
-
Easily produce giant prints10m 15s
-
Luna Display4m 19s
-
Choosing film7m 50s
-
Photo fads4m 46s
-
Portrait lighting techniques8m 32s
-
Diopter control2m 56s
-
Loupedeck for Lightroom6m 48s
-
Printing small3m 37s
-
Lens flare removal6m 28s
-
Paper choice for prints7m 39s
-
Aspect ratio for portraits2m 33s
-
When in doubt2m 24s
-
Looking vs. seeing2m 44s
-
Do you need a carnet?5m 23s
-
Scan large items6m 17s
-
Create an honest portrait5m 34s
-
A portrait assignment3m 23s
-
Am I good?5m 59s
-
Boredom4m 13s
-
Clichés4m 29s
-
Finding inspiration5m 42s
-
An everyday project5m 47s
-
Learning from students4m 56s
-
Life as a project5m 27s
-
Why take a workshop?4m 33s
-
Photographic honesty2m 52s
-
Up to interpretation3m 27s
-
Photographic style3m 40s
-
Photography drills6m 31s
-
Digital chores4m 23s
-
Photos and words4m 11s
-
Stay-at-home exercises3m 45s
-
Understanding your medium2m 28s
-
Darkroom for iOS5m 15s
-
iOS image editing extensions2m 58s
-
On set: Simplicity4m 5s
-
On set: Corners2m 19s
-
On set: The build4m 30s
-
On set: Same pieces, new set3m 18s
-
Choose a price first3m 20s
-
Rewind: Choosing a camera5m 41s
-
On time and in tune3m 3s
-
Avalanche for aperture4m 8s
-
Evaluating a wide-angle lens6m 14s
-
Auction catalogs4m 56s
-
Get out and shoot (safely)3m 45s
-
Do ruts exist?2m 24s
-
- Mark as unwatched
- Mark all as unwatched
Are you sure you want to mark all the videos in this course as unwatched?
This will not affect your course history, your reports, or your certificates of completion for this course.
CancelTake notes with your new membership!
Type in the entry box, then click Enter to save your note.
1:30Press on any video thumbnail to jump immediately to the timecode shown.
Notes are saved with you account but can also be exported as plain text, MS Word, PDF, Google Doc, or Evernote.
Share this video
Embed this video
Video: Stitching together stacks of stars