Join Ben Long for an in-depth discussion in this video Comparing the Fuji GFX and the Hasselblad X1D, part of The Practicing Photographer.
- I'm sitting here right now with the Fuji GFX 50S and the Hasselblad X1D. These are both medium format digital cameras. If you're wondering what medium format is, or if you've been wondering whether maybe medium format is something that you could use, I've got an entire course on medium format photography that will mostly answer all of those questions for you. What I'm going to do here today at The Practicing Photographer since I've got both of these cameras here, is kind of give you my opinion of these two cameras going head to head. This is going to be some exciting camera comparison action going on right here.
I don't want to talk about why you might want these, what advantages you get from medium format. Again, we got a whole course on that. I just want to talk about the differences as medium format cameras, between these two models. Both of these, let's get this out of the way right off the bat, both of these cameras produce spectacular images. They both use the same sensor. They produce different images, even though they're using the same sensor. Both companies have modified the sensor. Both of them process their raw files in different ways. Neither camera is so far off the other that one can't be adjusted to look like the other, and the level of detail that you get, these are 50 megapixel sensors.
The level of detail you get is astonishing. The dynamic range is spectacular, and both cameras have very, very good iSO response, comparable to what you'd find from a very good full frame camera. They both have very good lens selections. They both come in at under $10,000. The GFX is cheaper by several thousand dollars, but it's larger. The Hasselblad is smaller, easier to tote around. There are these obvious physical differences.
This camera has a focal-plane shutter, which is probably what you're used to using in the camera that you already have. This camera, the Hasselblad, has a leaf shutter, which means that you will be able to sync flashes with any shutter speed on this camera. If you do a lot of flash work, that's a great advantage. Both of these cameras have their strengths and weaknesses. I will say right now, I'll just cut to the chase, I prefer the Fuji. And I prefer the Fuji for a number of usability reasons. One of the most, and I'm going to start with the one that's kind of the most surprising to me.
I was working with the Hasselblad the other night and it crashed, it had to restart itself. I've been reviewing cameras for various magazines and whatnot since 1998. I have never had a camera crash before. It threw an error and said I got to restart. So there's just a lot about this camera that I feel like it's not done. I feel like I'm using a beta unit, and I've checked and I'm running the latest firmware. There are other things. Boot time on this camera is between five and 10 seconds, meaning from the time I press the power button, I can't shoot for another five or 10 seconds.
I'm used to cameras that pop on automatically. I walk around with the camera off. When I see something I want to shoot, as I'm raising the camera to my eye, I turn it on and it's ready to go when I get there. I can't work that way with this camera, which makes me feel less comfortable about managing battery life, and so on and so forth. I do not have any of those kinds of stability problems with the Fuji. So those two things right off the bat are pretty big things to me that make me worry about this camera. I do trust that Hasselblad will fix the crashes, and I know they already have improved the boot time from, it used to be worse than this is now.
They're being very diligent about firmware updates, which I think is really nice. They have added features to this camera since its release. Now, those were features that I felt like it should have come with, but they're being diligent about working on their software, and the updates that are coming out are clean and functional, so that's great. In fact, by the time you see this, the things that I've just mentioned may be totally taken care of. Fuji is also very good across their entire range of cameras with firmware updates. You will get a lot of software support from both of these vendors.
Again, both cameras produce excellent image quality. The Fuji can go two stops higher on its iSO rating. Now, those two stops, that's going from 25,000 to 50,000 to 100,000, those two stops are very, very noisy. They're still usable in a pinch, in certain situations, so if you do a whole lot of low light shooting, you may find that you want those extra two stops. I haven't actually used them except in camera testing. Obviously if size is a critical concern for you, this camera, the Hasselblad, is easier to tote around.
The lenses are smaller for the most part, the camera body is much smaller. The reason the lenses are smaller is because with the small body size they can get the lenses closer to the sensor. Everything about this camera is smaller. It's still roughly the size of a full frame digital SLR, but it is definitely smaller than the Fuji, which you may not have been able to tell. It's very deep, it's got this big, boxy thing on the back end of it. One of the things that boxy thing gets you is an articulated view screen, which I really, really like.
The Hasselblad does not have that. I am used to working with a camera like this on a tripod. I really like being able to pull that out. Both these cameras have touch screens, which is really nice. Both of them are mirrorless cameras, meaning they both have electronic viewfinders, and I will say outright that the Fuji EVF, the Fuji electronic viewfinder is much nicer than the Hasselblad one. The Hasselblad one looks a little washed out to me. Refresh rates are fine. The rear LCD screens are great on both cameras. They both deliver a very clear image.
The touch screen functionality is very, very nice. One of the most subjective things about evaluating a camera is interface and usability, and I don't mean interface of the menus. I mean interface of the entire unit. There are Canon people and there are Nikon people. I would argue that Canon people don't mind having functionality doubled up on a few buttons, while Nikon people prefer lots of buttons so that they can directly manipulate everything. Those are two different approaches. One is neither better nor worse, they're just different.
If you approach an interface in a particular way, you might prefer one of those to the other. I would argue the same thing here. Hasselblad is asking you to do most things through their touch screen interface. It's a very pretty touch screen interface and it's one that flows and is easy to find your way around. There are some nomenclature things that I think are a little odd, but once you learn them, you get them and you can learn them very quickly. Fuji has an iSO dial here, and a shutter speed dial here, and an aperture ring here, and I've got, the camera is littered with buttons, all of which are customizable.
I can put all sorts of functions. I've got a button up here. I've got one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight buttons back here, all of which are customizable. I can set up buttons to do just about anything I want to do on this camera. And it turns out I prefer working that way. I find I can move faster. I don't have to take the camera down from my eye to do lots of changes. This, I have to come down, look through menus. I'm not as comfortable with that. I can argue that this is a great way to work because I come down here, I do some things on my touch screen.
Once I know where they are they go very quickly. I can work just fine. That's just not how my mind works. I'm liking this better. You need to get your hands on both of these cameras before you make that kind of decision. You need to get your hands on both of these cameras because at this price point, you shouldn't buy these cameras unless you got a really good return policy without really feeling what they're like. They're big, they're heavy. They're not as big as other medium format cameras. They're not as big as some SLRs with larger lenses. You should also check out the lens selection for both of these cameras. Make sure that lenses that you're used to using, that there's an equivalent for them here.
You're not going to find super long telephoto lenses for these cameras. You're not going to find super fast glass for either of these cameras. Hasselblad, I think right now has an edge in the lens department, because you can buy a Hasselblad made adapter that allows you to use their excellent H series lenses with this camera. That broadens the field right away. Fuji has a good lineup so far, a roadmap for a better lineup. They're moving quickly and they're moving well. Both companies make exceptional lenses. And that's one of the big reasons that these cameras produce such great images, is when you're buying into this level of camera, you're buying into a lens selection that is expensive, but you get what you pay for with it.
You get really, really great optics. So whether medium format is right for you is another question. If you decide it is, and you're going to come down to one of these cameras, they both have their advantages. My predilection is for the Fuji. The Hasselblad is still a great camera. It just needs a little software work to really get it up to where it needs to be.
Author
Updated
4/2/2021Released
5/19/2013Skill Level Beginner
Duration
Views
Q: Why can't I earn a Certificate of Completion for this course?
A: We publish a new tutorial or tutorials for this course on a regular basis. We are unable to offer a Certificate of Completion because it is an ever-evolving course that is not designed to be completed. Check back often for new movies.
Related Courses
-
Photography Foundations: Composition
with Ben Long5h 29m Intermediate -
The DIY Photographer
with Joseph "PhotoJoseph" Linaschke2h 39m Intermediate -
Photo Tools Weekly
with Chris Orwig26h 18m Intermediate
-
The Practicing Photographer - New This Week
-
Introduction
-
Previous Episodes
-
Choosing a camera5m 27s
-
Let your lens reshape you7m 26s
-
Working with reflections1m 26s
-
Exploring mirrorless cameras7m 25s
-
Using a tripod3m 33s
-
Wildlife and staying present5m 58s
-
Why Shoot Polaroid11m 12s
-
Seizing an opportunity4m 4s
-
Shooting wildlife7m 24s
-
Using a lens hood4m 48s
-
Working with themes2m 48s
-
Setting up an HDR time lapse7m 55s
-
Processing an HDR time lapse7m 55s
-
Scanning Photos5m 37s
-
Jpeg iPad import process3m 17s
-
Warming up3m 26s
-
Taking a panning action shot10m 17s
-
Shooting a silhouette3m 9s
-
Using Lightroom on the road6m 28s
-
Shooting level2m 42s
-
Photoshop and Automator8m 54s
-
Softboxes vs. umbrellas2m 55s
-
Working with hair in post3m 28s
-
Exploring how to use Bokeh5m 38s
-
Shooting stills from a drone6m 57s
-
Working with models2m 40s
-
Tips for shooting panoramas7m 16s
-
Dry sensor cleaning6m 23s
-
Composing in the center2m 48s
-
Vignetting9m 56s
-
Inspire3m 29s
-
Minimizing camera baggage4m 24s
-
Working without a tripod4m 11s
-
Printer options6m 51s
-
Exploring lo-fi printing options11m 58s
-
IOS macro photography gear12m 25s
-
IR Conversion Part 27m 27s
-
Raw editing in Lightroom mobile10m 35s
-
Shooting a macro insect shot13m 5s
-
A brief history of photography12m 19s
-
Shooting with a Petzval lens9m 49s
-
What is a low-pass filter?4m 35s
-
Teleconverters and lenses5m 12s
-
Media card care7m 19s
-
Dual slot4m 2s
-
Exploring smart previews9m 12s
-
Flying and photo batteries5m 41s
-
Partial vignettes on photos8m 38s
-
360 image editing plugins6m 59s
-
Using a gimbal with an SLR8m 13s
-
Choosing a lens6m 27s
-
Switching camera systems7m 42s
-
Using 360 drones5m 41s
-
VR gimbals4m 16s
-
Working with a photo subject14m 26s
-
Posing a photo subject12m 53s
-
Framing and safety7m 7s
-
RAW converter options3m 59s
-
Drone flight7m 19s
-
Basic abstract photography8m 51s
-
Aspect ratio3m 40s
-
Focus lock on your camera2m 11s
-
Using the Astropad app6m 33s
-
Working with dim sunlight6m 33s
-
Configuring dual cards2m 52s
-
Long lens options4m 45s
-
Moving images from catalogs7m 47s
-
Photography education11m 7s
-
In-camera focus stacking9m 52s
-
Exposure isn't everything4m 17s
-
Why shoot film?8m 55s
-
Culling4m
-
Choosing a film camera8m 38s
-
Analog workflow9m 9s
-
Easily produce giant prints10m 15s
-
Luna Display4m 19s
-
Choosing film7m 50s
-
Photo fads4m 46s
-
Portrait lighting techniques8m 32s
-
Diopter control2m 56s
-
Loupedeck for Lightroom6m 48s
-
Printing small3m 37s
-
Lens flare removal6m 28s
-
Paper choice for prints7m 39s
-
Aspect ratio for portraits2m 33s
-
When in doubt2m 24s
-
Looking vs. seeing2m 44s
-
Do you need a carnet?5m 23s
-
Scan large items6m 17s
-
Create an honest portrait5m 34s
-
A portrait assignment3m 23s
-
Am I good?5m 59s
-
Boredom4m 13s
-
Clichés4m 29s
-
Finding inspiration5m 42s
-
An everyday project5m 47s
-
Learning from students4m 56s
-
Life as a project5m 27s
-
Why take a workshop?4m 33s
-
Photographic honesty2m 52s
-
Up to interpretation3m 27s
-
Photographic style3m 40s
-
Photography drills6m 31s
-
Digital chores4m 23s
-
Photos and words4m 11s
-
Stay-at-home exercises3m 45s
-
Understanding your medium2m 28s
-
Darkroom for iOS5m 15s
-
iOS image editing extensions2m 58s
-
On set: Simplicity4m 5s
-
On set: Corners2m 19s
-
On set: The build4m 30s
-
On set: Same pieces, new set3m 18s
-
Choose a price first3m 20s
-
Rewind: Choosing a camera5m 41s
-
On time and in tune3m 3s
-
Avalanche for aperture4m 8s
-
Evaluating a wide-angle lens6m 14s
-
Auction catalogs4m 56s
-
Get out and shoot (safely)3m 45s
-
Do ruts exist?2m 24s
-
16-bit in Photoshop6m 23s
-
The artist's statement2m 42s
-
Constraints4m 55s
-
Check your goal2m 11s
-
Two kinds of seeing4m 18s
-
Photographers to consider1m 50s
-
- Mark as unwatched
- Mark all as unwatched
Are you sure you want to mark all the videos in this course as unwatched?
This will not affect your course history, your reports, or your certificates of completion for this course.
CancelTake notes with your new membership!
Type in the entry box, then click Enter to save your note.
1:30Press on any video thumbnail to jump immediately to the timecode shown.
Notes are saved with you account but can also be exported as plain text, MS Word, PDF, Google Doc, or Evernote.
Share this video
Embed this video
Video: Comparing the Fuji GFX and the Hasselblad X1D