Easy-to-follow video tutorials help you learn software, creative, and business skills.Become a member

The case for not feathering selections

From: Photoshop CC Selections and Layer Masking Workshop

Video: The case for not feathering selections

One of the options available to you when you're creating selections in Photoshop is to feather that selection. You can perform the feathering as part of the process of creating the selection or you can apply the feathering after the selection has already been created. But my recommendation is to not feather selections. Now I'll be the first to tell that when it comes to utilizing that selection you always or at least almost always want a feathered result and yet I never feather selections. Well, okay, I feather selections only when I'm showing someone why I'd recommend not feathering selections. So let's feather some selections so that you can see why I recommend not feathering those selections.

The case for not feathering selections

One of the options available to you when you're creating selections in Photoshop is to feather that selection. You can perform the feathering as part of the process of creating the selection or you can apply the feathering after the selection has already been created. But my recommendation is to not feather selections. Now I'll be the first to tell that when it comes to utilizing that selection you always or at least almost always want a feathered result and yet I never feather selections. Well, okay, I feather selections only when I'm showing someone why I'd recommend not feathering selections. So let's feather some selections so that you can see why I recommend not feathering those selections.

Instead essentially saving that step for later in your work flow. I'll start off by creating a selection of the sky here. I'm not going to worry that it's a perfect selection. I just want to be able to illustrate the concept here. Now this image, of course, is rather subtle. But we're not going to be subtle at all when it comes to applying a targeted adjustment in this case. So I've created a selection. But it is not a feathered selection. I'm using the Quick Selection tool here and it does not feather the selection in any appreciable way or it doesn't offer any way an option to adjust the feathering as part of the selection creation process.

But we could feather the selection after the fact. Well, let's take a look at why you need to have the effect of a feathered selection in the first place. I'm just going to add an adjustment layer here. So I'll add a curves adjustment layer. And then I'm going to apply an exaggerated adjustment for curves. This is in no means aimed at trying to produce a good result in the image. I'm simply trying to make sure that we have a very obvious effect in the sky. And so I'll create a dramatic adjustment that darkens down that sky a bit. And I think even without zooming in you'll be able to clearly see that we have a little bit of an issue here.

The transition between the area that's being adjusted and the area that's not being adjusted is rather harsh. So we need some transition there. Maybe just the tiny, tiny bit of transition. But we do need some transition nevertheless. I'm going to reload my selection. Now don't worry about the particular steps on performing here. Just focus on the effect of this feathering. Because I want you to understand that concept first and foremost at the moment. So I have that selection once again. This is as we have already seen, a non- feathered selection. So let's go ahead and feather the selection so that we'll get a smoother transition between the adjusted versus non adjusted areas. I'll go to the select menu, and I'm going to choose modify followed by feather. That will bring up the feather selection dialogue where I can enter in the number of pixels by which I would like to feather the selection. And there's the rub.

I don't know, I have no idea how many pixels I would need to feather this selection by in order to get a smooth transition. or more to the point an appropriate transition based on the area of the image that I'm working on as well as the strength of my adjustment, because I'll need to be much more careful about that feathering, about that transition when I'm working with a very, very strong adjustment. I'm not sure what to do. Well, I actually, of course, from experience have a pretty good sense of what numbers I might use in terms of this radius value in different situations. But let's just assume that I figure maybe ten pixels will be a good feathering. I'll click OK.

My selection is now feathered. And so I'm going to add another curves adjustment. And I'll apply a similar adjustment to this curve right about there. And I'll pull the black point in and bring that curve down a little bit. And I'm sure you can see a rather obvious effect. Fact there, I'll zoom out just a little bit. We have this halo effect, so I'm darkening the sky, but there's a transition between the sky and the building. So I'm blending that adjustment into the building a little bit, and also of course transitioning so that the edge of the sky has that halo effect. I'm darkening a lot here and then not darkening quite as much until we get to the point where there is no more darkening.

So it would appear that that feathering of ten pixels was way too much. So I need less feathering. I'll go ahead and turn off my curves two adjustment layer, and I'll reload my original selection. I'll go to the Select menu. I'll choose Modify followed by Feather. I'll try five pixels and click OK. And I'll create yet another curves adjustment. Now of course under normal circumstances you wouldn't be creating multiple adjustment layers. You would just be using the right technique in the first place. And you can see that I still have a little bit too much feathering. And this is the crux of the problem.

When you're feathering a selection you don't necessarily know how much to feather by. The alternative, though, is very, very easy. I'll go ahead and turn off that Curves adjustment layer and I'm going to go back to my original Curves adjustment layer. You'll recall that this adjustment had no feathering at all, and so the transition is rather abrupt. But now I'm going to go to the properties panel and choose the masks option, and you'll see that I can feather my layer mask. In other words, I'm feathering the selection After I've created an effect with that selection. So, in this case, I used the selection as the basis of a layer mask with an adjustment layer.

Don' t worry about the particulars of all of that, but just bear in mind, that when you're creating a selection, you're probably going to be using it for some particular purpose. And, in the context of creating composite images or applying adjustments that only affect a specific portion of the image, it's better to apply that feathering based on the final effect in the image. In other words, in this case, based on the actual adjustment. So I'll click on my curves adjustment layer to make sure that the layer mask is active, and now I can feather. I'll go ahead and bring this value up to ten, for example, and you'll see that we get exactly the same result as thought we had feathered the selection by 10 pixels. And now when I see that too much, I don't have to undo a couple of steps and redo some steps and make changes.

I simply drag a slider to a different position. And so I can fine tune the degree of feathering after the fact. Now of course in this case, the selection was far from perfect, and the adjustment is absurdly exaggerated. But the point here was not to create a good adjustment for the sky, obviously. But rather to illustrate this concept of feathering. So this illustrates the reason why I never feather selections, except to show you why it's best not to feather selections, and instead to essentially feather the result, to feather whatever it is that you're doing with that selection later in your workflow.

Show transcript

This video is part of

Image for Photoshop CC Selections and Layer Masking Workshop
Photoshop CC Selections and Layer Masking Workshop

51 video lessons · 11255 viewers

Tim Grey
Author

 
Expand all | Collapse all
  1. 1m 27s
    1. Welcome
      1m 27s
  2. 46m 26s
    1. Selections, alpha channels, and layer masks, oh my!
      5m 48s
    2. Anti-aliasing and selections
      6m 6s
    3. The case for not feathering selections
      6m 50s
    4. Adding, subtracting, and intersecting
      7m 31s
    5. Inverting a selection
      3m 4s
    6. Mixing and matching selection tools
      2m 32s
    7. Using Deselect and Reselect
      3m 47s
    8. Temporarily hiding a selection
      2m 7s
    9. Saving and loading selections
      6m 14s
    10. Using the cursor for selections
      2m 27s
  3. 51m 42s
    1. The Rectangular Marquee tool
      8m 24s
    2. The Elliptical Marquee tool
      6m 2s
    3. The Lasso tool
      4m 55s
    4. The Polygonal Lasso tool
      6m 27s
    5. The Magnetic Lasso tool
      10m 9s
    6. The Quick Selection tool
      5m 33s
    7. The Magic Wand tool
      10m 12s
  4. 38m 38s
    1. Selecting the border of an existing selection
      1m 50s
    2. The Color Range command
      7m 19s
    3. Focusing a Color Range selection
      2m 55s
    4. Selecting faces with Color Range
      2m 31s
    5. The Pen tool
      5m 40s
    6. Selecting by luminosity
      3m 39s
    7. Selecting from a channel
      6m 13s
    8. Transforming a selection
      4m 4s
    9. Quick Mask mode
      4m 27s
  5. 50m 46s
    1. Combining layers into a single document
      1m 49s
    2. Layering images manually
      1m 55s
    3. Assembling a panorama automatically
      3m 1s
    4. Advanced blending
      4m 0s
    5. Painting to hide and reveal
      3m 24s
    6. Creating a selection-based composite
      2m 43s
    7. Select, then paint
      3m 28s
    8. Advanced mask cleanup
      6m 18s
    9. Creating an edge-fade effect
      2m 23s
    10. Using a filter to add an artistic edge
      3m 6s
    11. Using a brush effect to add an artistic edge
      5m 30s
    12. Transforming a masked object
      1m 51s
    13. Unlinking image and mask
      2m 53s
    14. Matching composite images
      2m 17s
    15. Adding layer effects with masks
      2m 21s
    16. Reviewing layer masks
      3m 47s
  6. 28m 58s
    1. Painting in an adjustment
      3m 20s
    2. Shades of gray
      3m 14s
    3. Using the Gradient tool
      4m 4s
    4. Adjusting a selected area
      1m 42s
    5. Creating a vignette effect with masking
      2m 13s
    6. Using a layer group
      3m 34s
    7. Working with multiple masks
      4m 5s
    8. Refining an adjustment mask
      6m 46s

Start learning today

Get unlimited access to all courses for just $25/month.

Become a member
Sometimes @lynda teaches me how to use a program and sometimes Lynda.com changes my life forever. @JosefShutter
@lynda lynda.com is an absolute life saver when it comes to learning todays software. Definitely recommend it! #higherlearning @Michael_Caraway
@lynda The best thing online! Your database of courses is great! To the mark and very helpful. Thanks! @ru22more
Got to create something yesterday I never thought I could do. #thanks @lynda @Ngventurella
I really do love @lynda as a learning platform. Never stop learning and developing, it’s probably our greatest gift as a species! @soundslikedavid
@lynda just subscribed to lynda.com all I can say its brilliant join now trust me @ButchSamurai
@lynda is an awesome resource. The membership is priceless if you take advantage of it. @diabetic_techie
One of the best decision I made this year. Buy a 1yr subscription to @lynda @cybercaptive
guys lynda.com (@lynda) is the best. So far I’ve learned Java, principles of OO programming, and now learning about MS project @lucasmitchell
Signed back up to @lynda dot com. I’ve missed it!! Proper geeking out right now! #timetolearn #geek @JayGodbold
Share a link to this course

What are exercise files?

Exercise files are the same files the author uses in the course. Save time by downloading the author's files instead of setting up your own files, and learn by following along with the instructor.

Can I take this course without the exercise files?

Yes! If you decide you would like the exercise files later, you can upgrade to a premium account any time.

Become a member Download sample files See plans and pricing

Please wait... please wait ...
Upgrade to get access to exercise files.

Exercise files video

How to use exercise files.

Learn by watching, listening, and doing, Exercise files are the same files the author uses in the course, so you can download them and follow along Premium memberships include access to all exercise files in the library.


Exercise files

Exercise files video

How to use exercise files.

For additional information on downloading and using exercise files, watch our instructional video or read the instructions in the FAQ.

This course includes free exercise files, so you can practice while you watch the course. To access all the exercise files in our library, become a Premium Member.

Join now "Already a member? Log in

Are you sure you want to mark all the videos in this course as unwatched?

This will not affect your course history, your reports, or your certificates of completion for this course.


Mark all as unwatched Cancel

Congratulations

You have completed Photoshop CC Selections and Layer Masking Workshop.

Return to your organization's learning portal to continue training, or close this page.


OK
Become a member to add this course to a playlist

Join today and get unlimited access to the entire library of video courses—and create as many playlists as you like.

Get started

Already a member?

Become a member to like this course.

Join today and get unlimited access to the entire library of video courses.

Get started

Already a member?

Exercise files

Learn by watching, listening, and doing! Exercise files are the same files the author uses in the course, so you can download them and follow along. Exercise files are available with all Premium memberships. Learn more

Get started

Already a Premium member?

Exercise files video

How to use exercise files.

Ask a question

Thanks for contacting us.
You’ll hear from our Customer Service team within 24 hours.

Please enter the text shown below:

The classic layout automatically defaults to the latest Flash Player.

To choose a different player, hold the cursor over your name at the top right of any lynda.com page and choose Site preferencesfrom the dropdown menu.

Continue to classic layout Stay on new layout
Exercise files

Access exercise files from a button right under the course name.

Mark videos as unwatched

Remove icons showing you already watched videos if you want to start over.

Control your viewing experience

Make the video wide, narrow, full-screen, or pop the player out of the page into its own window.

Interactive transcripts

Click on text in the transcript to jump to that spot in the video. As the video plays, the relevant spot in the transcript will be highlighted.

Are you sure you want to delete this note?

No

Your file was successfully uploaded.

Thanks for signing up.

We’ll send you a confirmation email shortly.


Sign up and receive emails about lynda.com and our online training library:

Here’s our privacy policy with more details about how we handle your information.

Keep up with news, tips, and latest courses with emails from lynda.com.

Sign up and receive emails about lynda.com and our online training library:

Here’s our privacy policy with more details about how we handle your information.

   
submit Lightbox submit clicked
Terms and conditions of use

We've updated our terms and conditions (now called terms of service).Go
Review and accept our updated terms of service.